Should Paul Pierce go No. 1 in an all-time Boston Celtics Draft?

Paul Pierce boasted one of the greatest careers in Boston Celtics history before his 2017 retirement with the team. Since then, he’s taken his handful of losses: on social media, on the air with his predictions and in a quarantine HORSE showcase from his backyard court.

Gary Washburn then delivered him a post-career accolade on par with his NBA Finals MVP trophy. The Boston Globe held an all-time Celtics draft and Washburn, with the paper since 2009, selected him with the first overall pick. Backlash ensued from ardent Bill Russell and Larry Bird supporters, so Washburn joined Bob Ryan and Jeff Goodman’s CLNS Media podcast to defend his selection.

“It’s a fantasy draft,” Washburn said. “I put up the player, who’s going to put up the numbers, who has a transcendent game, who would’ve been able to play in the 50s, 60s and 70s, because of his size, his girth, his mid-range game. It’s not the greatest Celtic of all-time.”

Pierce ranked second in points, first in three-pointers and seventh in rebounds in Celtics history. Washburn argued that he could fill up all the stat categories in any era more than any other Celtic across all eras. Larry Bird, he said, would be the only other one in the conversation.

“I wish people would stop saying I think Pierce is a better player than Bill Russell,” Washburn said. “Fantasy-wise? Yes. You would choose Peyton Manning over Brady, because Peyton puts up more numbers. Brady’s a better winner.”

Adam Himmelsbach did not state explicitly in his article that the draft hinged on fantasy performance. Washburn selected Pierce, Jayson Tatum (9), Dennis Johnson (11), Isaiah Thomas (20) and Kendrick Perkins (21) with his first five selections. Bob Ryan, who picked strictly for winning, took Dave Cowens (5), Kevin McHale (6), Tiny Archibald (15), Sam Jones (16) and Jaylen Brown (25).

Danny Ainge, in rating the teams, picked Ryan (4th) and Washburn (5th) last behind Dan Schaunessy, Chad Finn and Himmelsbach.

“We’re having a tournament,” Ryan said. “I’m trying to win. We approached it two different ways.”

Ryan said the reaction to picking John Havlicek would not have reached the level of confusion Washburn received for Pierce. The Celtics Mt. Rushmore is clearly Russell, Bird, Havlicek and Bob Cousy. Pierce and Kevin McHale sit just outside.

The cast also discussed Kyrie Irving’s Celtics tenure and what they remember about his time with the team and where his career projects to go. Washburn never had any issues with him, but found him unhappy and swaying between emotions. A source once told him there are five different Irvings.

“I’m not denying these arguments,” Washburn said. “But like I told Schaunessy, it’s like I took John Bagley first. I took the franchise’s second-leading scorer and I’m getting you don’t know basketball.”

Bobby Manning

Boston Celtics beat reporter for CLNS Media and host of the Garden Report Celtics Post Game Show. NBA national columnist for Boston Sports Journal. Contributor to SB Nation's CelticsBlog. Host of the Dome Theory Sports and Culture Podcast on CLNS. Syracuse University 2020.

Recent Posts

Patriots Top Breakout Candidates: Offense

With question marks surrounding the Patriots' offensive roster and coaching staff, expectations are low for…

30 mins ago

Sam Hauser Agrees to Four-Year, $45 Million Extension with Celtics

Sam Hauser and the Celtics agreed to a four-year, $45 million fully guaranteed extension that carries…

13 hours ago

Do the Bruins have what it takes to trade for Leon Draisaitl?

Pucks with Haggs host Joe Haggerty and guest Mick Colageo answer Bruins fan questions, including…

15 hours ago

Patriots notes, quotes, and anecdotes: It’s Training Camp week!

Good morning, happy Sunday, and welcome back into another edition of ‘Patriots notes, quotes, &…

1 day ago

Celtics Summer League Studs and Duds

A. Sherrod Blakely is joined by Noa Dalzell of Celtics Blog to discuss reflections and…

2 days ago

Jeremy Swayman, Fabian Lysell and Stanley Cup Contention

Evan Marinofsky, filling in for Conor Ryan, welcomes Scott McLaughlin of WEEI to discuss some…

3 days ago